The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Preliminary thoughts on end-of-year polls

Home Forums Archive Topics Preliminary thoughts on end-of-year polls

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 62 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #5468
    Prufrock
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2081

    <b>The following categories and nominations came about as a result of the Southern meeting on 24/10. The purpose of the exercise was to provide a starting point for categories and nominations in advance of running some end-of-year polls, probably in about a month’s time. What has been missed out? And what has been included that shouldn’t have been?</b>

    POSTER OF THE YEAR
    Kingston Town, David Johnson, Reet Hard, Cormack and APRacing.

    HERO OF THE YEAR
    Barney Curley, Sheikh Mohammed, Clive Smith, Jim Bolger and Henry Cecil.

    VILLAIN OF THE YEAR (we avoided some of the more "sensitive" choices)
    Barney Curley, Kirkland Tellwright, Lord Donoughue, BBC Radio 5 and Julian Wislon.

    HORSE OF THE YEAR
    Kauto Star, Manduro, Katchit, Dylan Thomas, New Approach and My Way de Solzen.

    JOCKEY OF THE YEAR
    Richard Hills, Nina Carberry, Ryan Moore, Seb Sanders, Jamie Spencer, Jimmy Fortune, Tony McCoy and Ruby Walsh.

    TRAINER OF THE YEAR
    Paul Nicholls, Peter Chapple-Hyam, Alan King, Henry Cecil, John Gosden, Jim Bolger, Aidan O’Brien and Richard Newland.

    OWNER OF THE YEAR
    Clive Smith, Godolphin, John Magnier, Harry Findlay, Cheveley Park Stud and The Comic Strip Heroes.

    JOURNALIST OF THE YEAR
    Alex Hankin, Lydia Hislop, Greg Wood, Alan Lee, James Willoughby, Nick Mordin and David Ashforth.

    COMMENTATOR OF THE YEAR
    Richard Hoiles, Simon Holt, John Hunt, Jerry Hannon and Neville Ender.

    BROADCASTER OF THE YEAR
    Matt Chapman, Steve Mellish, Nick Luck, Sean Boyce and Jonathon Neesom.

    RACECOURSE OF THE YEAR
    Goodwood, Cartmel, Kempton, Market Rasen, Dundalk and Doncaster

    RIDE OF THE YEAR
    Richard Hills on Maraahel (Newbury 21/4), Ryan Moore on Notnowcato (Sandown 07/7), Jamie Spencer on Red Evie (Newbury 18/8 ), Johnny Murtagh on Candidato Roy (Ascot 29/9) and Frankie Dettori on Ramonti (any of 3 wins).

    ONE TO WATCH FOR 2008
    William Buick, Mick Halford, Great Leighs (or possibly 2009…2010…2011…) and Nick Scholfield.

    #121330
    Gareth Flynn
    Participant
    • Total Posts 583

    Only addition I’d suggest is putting Johnny Murtagh in the Jockey category.

    #121331
    Avatar photoyeats
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3701

    Matt Chapman ??? Broadcaster of the Year ??? :shock:

    #121334
    thedarkknight
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1299

    What is going on with the Owner of the year category?

    Godolphin? On what possible basis could they be in the running?

    (and the Comic Strip Heroes nomination is surely too much of a suck up to the Betfair boys as well – have you no shame Prufrock :lol: ?)

    #121335
    Avatar photoGazs Way De Solzen
    Member
    • Total Posts 2440

    Agree with Godolphin not being in there.

    They have been awful i think up until the last month or so.

    #121336
    thedarkknight
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1299

    John Mayne should definitely be on the list btw.

    #121337
    clivex
    Member
    • Total Posts 3420

    Why?

    hes been brown bread for years and i never liked his films anyway :roll:

    #121344
    Avatar photoAndrew Hughes
    Member
    • Total Posts 1904

    I would add MickyMo and Davejay to poster of the year

    #121348
    Ugly Mare
    Member
    • Total Posts 1294

    ooh this is fun. Here’s some of mine:

    Poster: I don’t like to mention names and the 4 or 5 that I would name already know who they are, as they’ve either made me laugh hysterically, or been most courteous and generous one way or another, or for simply giving me the time of day :D

    Hero: Henry Cecil, as always good grace, strength and fortitude.
    Villain: Richard Hughes – I’m sorry Richard but my pocket says you’ve done me no favours this year sweetheart.
    Horse: Katchit – for one kept on the go so long and still retained it’s form in one of the seasons most gruelling events for young horses.
    Jockey: Seb Sanders for being such a grafter
    Hayley Turner for the ability to make it in a man’s world.

    Trainer: William Knight [please don’t ask why]
    Owner: Hucking Horses, for giving me a hucking good laugh.
    Journalist: Lydia Hislop
    Commentator: Simon Holt/Darren Owen
    Broadcaster: Matt Chapman, Lydia Hislop, and the always pleasant Alex Quinn.
    Racecourse: Brighton – for allowing me in.
    Ride of the Year: How dare you ask! – I’m not telling……….oh but if I must – Ryan Moore/Notnowcato
    One to Watch for 2008: David England

    so there :)

    next,,,

    #121349
    clivex
    Member
    • Total Posts 3420

    Ride of the Year: How dare you ask! – I’m not telling……….

    Well u wouldnt if it was Alan Berry or Mick Easterby ….would u?

    :shock:

    #121370
    SwallowCottage
    Member
    • Total Posts 1008

    POSTER OF THE YEAR — Others to consider in my opinion are Madman Marz, Non Vintage and Maxillion.

    RACECOURSE OF THE YEAR — what about Ascot :lol:

    #121375
    MikkyMo73
    Member
    • Total Posts 1789

    I would add MickyMo and Davejay to poster of the year

    Thanks Andrew.

    If there were a drunken poster of the year award, I would not only be in it, I think I would pish it, hic, hic.

    Mike,

    Categories are great BTW, when does voting commence? And can we have a ‘most blatant non trier’ of the year award just to keep Madman happy :lol:

    #121376
    dave jay
    Member
    • Total Posts 3386

    Lord Donoughue – definitely villian of the year, the way things are going it could be of the decade, well him and Saville.

    Armpit of the year, Kempton.

    Poster of the year, Prufrock

    #121378
    Flash
    Member
    • Total Posts 1144

    Matt Chapman broadcaster of the year nominee?????

    He was added for a laugh surely? That cannot be serious!!

    #121384
    Avatar photoCav
    Participant
    • Total Posts 4833

    POSTER OF THE YEAR

    Glenn – His "The Beverley Heist" post could have graced the pages of any broadsheet.

    NB – Dave Jay, he should be running the sport.

    APracing off the list this year, obviously a man who knows his racing but his infrequent posts these days certainly don’t merit any adulation. Pity he doesn’t contribute more.

    HERO OF THE YEAR

    Ryan Moore – The personification of excellence, I’d love to know what he REALLY thinks.

    VILLIAN OF THE YEAR

    Irish Stewards – "Whatever you say, say nothing"

    HORSE OF THE YEAR

    Kauto Star – cant add anything to what’s already been said
    Ramonti – Beat the mob handed Ballydolye boys in the Sussex with an awesome dispaly of guts, his obscure pedigree prevent the plaudits, but he has a big fan here.

    TRAINER OF THE YEAR

    Sir Michael Stoute – Sustained excellence at the highest levels of the sport without the massive Arab/Irish firepower.

    OWNER OF THE YEAR

    Khalid Abdullah – None of the Godolphin hype, but a superb breeding and racing operation in its own right.

    COMMENTATOR OF THE YEAR

    They all do a good job, Richard Hoiles, Simon Holt and Mark Johnson all deserve special mention

    BROADCASTER OF THE YEAR

    Bit of a blanket category, interviewing, analysing, and presenting are all different skills

    Interrviewing – Nick Luck, asks the questions I’d ask myself
    Analysing – Steve Mellish, his instant recall is almost frightening
    Presenting – Matt Chapman, under all the front seems an informed and intelligent guy.

    JOURNALIST OF THE YEAR

    Lydia Hislop – Can have her off days (article today) but in full topical flow no one better. And she cares!

    RACECOURSE OF THE YEAR

    Goodwood – The most beautiful racecourse I’ve been to.

    RIDE OF THE YEAR

    Ryan Moore – Notnowcato in the Eclipse

    ONE TO WATCH FOR 2008

    Liam Jones, he’s better than Buick.

    #121387
    Flash
    Member
    • Total Posts 1144

    POSTER OF THE YEAR

    David Johnson

    HERO OF THE YEAR

    Jim Bolger

    VILLAIN OF THE YEAR

    Radio 5

    HORSE OF THE YEAR

    Kauto Star – How can it not be?

    JOCKEY OF THE YEAR

    Tony McCoy

    TRAINER OF THE YEAR

    Paul Nicholls

    OWNER OF THE YEAR

    Clive Smith

    JOURNALIST OF THE YEAR

    Lydia Hislop

    COMMENTATOR OF THE YEAR

    Richard Hoiles – Top, top class.

    BROADCASTER OF THE YEAR

    Nick Luck,

    RACECOURSE OF THE YEAR

    Dunno.

    RIDE OF THE YEAR

    Ryan Moore on Notnowcato (Sandown 07/7),

    ONE TO WATCH FOR 2008
    William Buick

    #121389
    Grey Desire
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1938

    Tim Vaughan & Tom Dascombe are two up & coming trainers who should be followed.

    Rowe Park deserves a mention in the horse of the year polls.
    From a stable more associated with the likes of Smart Guy round Fontwell this horses’ rate of progress has been absolutely extraordinary.
    Never thought that when he won his maiden (we ran Taj in that race) that 12 months later the horse would be considered for the Prix De L’Abbaye and judged by the result may not have been far away (next year perhaps??).

    From a similar stable John Long has to be applauded for the handling of his small string,especially multiple winners Cativo Cavallino (who also ran against Taj in another maiden at Lingers won by Al Qasi) and the much improved For Life.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 62 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.