The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

2015 Cheltenham Gold Cup

Home Forums Archive Topics Cheltenham Archive Cheltenham 2015 2015 Cheltenham Gold Cup

Viewing 17 posts - 171 through 187 (of 187 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #831153
    homersimpson
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3182

    That is my big worry. A Denman-esque performance as rivals fell away one by one. Just hope that due to been lightly raced he will come out of this none the worse.

    #831156
    Avatar photopatriot1
    Participant
    • Total Posts 989

    I hope they put Coneygree away for the season now as that must have taken a lot out of him. It will be interesting to see his schedule for next year. Definitely the King George but would Haydock be a bit tight for his style of running.

    And if they’re both fit and well do you think Mullins and Ricci would run both Djakadam and Vautour in next year’s Gold Cup?

    #831162
    Avatar photoThe Young Fella
    Blocked
    • Total Posts 2064

    What a wonderful horse. I am quite a softly spoken guy, but was yelling so loud for Coneygree. All the nonsense about Gloria Victis, Houblon Des Obeaux and novices can be disregarded now. That was superb – the sort of exuberant daredevil performance that Gloria Victis himself produced to initially hook me on racing.

    I agree that Coneygree should be put away for the season now. It would leave a sour taste if he turned up half-cooked on quick ground at Aintree or Leopardstown, especially if he did himself an injury. As to next year, I’m just hoping that Coneygree manages to stay sound through the summer and his pre-training. From there, I’d love to see him take a crack some of the big handicaps like the Hennessy or Racing Post Chase, plus the King George.

    Something to note for next year’s Gold Cup (if Coneygree gets his conditions) is that you need to travel to stay in the race with him. Don Poli usually needs niggling, which would not be ideal for holding a dangerous position. Placed horses Djakadam, Road To Riches and Holywell all travelled sweetly this year, while the grinders and overkeen horses were all well stuffed.

    Still, would you take 2/1 that Coneygree stays sound AND gets suitable ground in next year’s Gold Cup?

    #831184
    Avatar photoSteeplechasing
    Participant
    • Total Posts 6337

    I wouldn’t worry so much about his soundness. My concern would be that this all-out give-everything in every race must burn a horse out. It was one of the reasons I was cagey about him after Newbury. I’ve yet to see a horse that can continue putting up these gut-wrenching runs, and his half-brother, Carruthers had that same gung-ho style at the start of his career and, I think, burned himself out.

    I’d put him away now until well into next season and hope for the best. I take the point about the grinders struggling, but I think Don Poli does just what he has to do, and I think Vautour is a creature from another planet.

    #831190
    Avatar photoZamorston
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1141

    Hoping to get the ground he likes again is obviously the big thing that would hold you back regarding next year…I had a little go yesterday a 20/1 for next year anticipating a good run today….as I say though it’s more in hope thn anything else….
    t
    If you could guarantee now that it would be soft ground next year I would have him as favourite…..I’m absolutely convinced he would have beaten Don Poli in the RSA…..Kings Palace poor mistakes let Don come back into the race on the bridle after briefly being nudged a few times….he also wasnt the best at a couple, whereas Coneygree jumps brilliantly….I just cant see any way how he would have gone past Coneygree on what we saw today….

    Vautour is different in my eyes, because he put up he performance of the week up to today (for me)….maybe best to many others….Vautour needs to prove he can travel and jump that well over a Gold Cup trip though with others putting pressure on, breathing down his neck the whole way….Coneygree proved that he is up to it today, and for me will keep on improving…

    If all the fancied horses so far do make it next year though it could be an absoulute classic…

    #831219
    Avatar photoGingertipster
    Participant
    • Total Posts 34704

    I wouldn’t worry so much about his soundness. My concern would be that this all-out give-everything in every race must burn a horse out. It was one of the reasons I was cagey about him after Newbury. I’ve yet to see a horse that can continue putting up these gut-wrenching runs, and his half-brother, Carruthers had that same gung-ho style at the start of his career and, I think, burned himself out.

    I’d put him away now until well into next season and hope for the best. I take the point about the grinders struggling, but I think Don Poli does just what he has to do, and I think Vautour is a creature from another planet.

    Carruthers was temperamental from an early stage in his chasing career Joe. Could give up if taken on.

    Coneygree reminds me a lot of the way Desert Orchid did things. And he went on for ages Joe. I don’t see the difference how a horse runs, they’re equally likely to get “burned out”. Possibly people don’t notice so much when non-front runners lose their enthusiasm because they’re only one of many and back in the field. When a front runner loses its enthusiasm it’s noticed.

    However, Coneygree is an eight year old, therefore has limited time at the top. He’s also had injuries in the past, so like any horse (front-runner or held up) who’s been fragile in the past – there’s a danger of a returning problem.

    Time of the Gold Cup puts a question mark against official ground conditions on the Chase course today. Racing Post say “Slow by 5.5 seconds”. Even with top class racehorses you’d expect a slower time at this distance on “Soft, good-soft in places” imo. More like an exceptional time on Good-Soft.

    imo All of last three starts were not run on ground as soft as the official going report. I think Coneygree will be effective on “Good” ground; although has a bit of a rounded action so may not be able to take much racing on that surface.

    Value Is Everything
    #831226
    Avatar photoZamorston
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1141

    A quick time comparison with last year shows it was some perfomance!

    Ran 2 seconds quicker than last year on slower ground….

    Comparing times of all other races on this day as opposed to last says it was a cracking time as it was the only time that was quicker…the rest were anything from 7 to 15 seconds slower than on this day last year!

    Never really been big into race times but the three he has run in his last 3 races suggest he’s a bit good…

    #831239
    Avatar photostevecaution
    Blocked
    • Total Posts 8241

    Although I’d had a small consolation bet on Coneygree after Newbury, I’d never say I fancied him and thought him awful value today. I hate getting the championship races so badly wrong, and I thought Many Clouds would win that, and that Bobs Worth would have done much better. I also fancied Sam Winner to run a race, so appalling calls from me. And I ended up screaming on Djakadam because I’d stuck him in one of those daft fiver accumulators, and the other three had won. All in all, a dreadful Gold Cup for me. The only saving grace is that, with Holywell’s performance, my @ass is safe from the view of TAPK

    I suppose that’s worth a lot, really!

    I didn’t see him as value either Joe, so you are not alone there.

    I was the opposite with Bobs Worth, because I had labelled him Sideshow Bob after his Lexus effort. Nicky says he doesn’t go on the soft but I don’t think it was that soft today and the fact of the matter is that Bobs Worth won his Gold Cup in a time of 7m 4.9s compared to 6m 42.7s clocked by today’s winner so I just can’t see where you could argue that the ground has done him in.

    Many Clouds, like Coneygree had form with Houblon Des Obeaux, who finished last of the 11 who completed today. Both horses increased their margin of superiority over Houblon today, but much more so in the case of the winner, who handed out a 42 length beating on this occasion, compared to the 7 lengths he had beaten him in The Denman chase. Even if we say Houblon has run poorly, Coneygree has made a lot more of that fact than Many Clouds did today. I always saw Many Clouds as more of a Grand National type and hope he runs there after this tough race.

    Silviniaco Conti hasn’t run to the expectations of his highest rating in the field. Probably Cheltenham isn’t his track and he was never allowed to dominate the way he has in some of his races on soft ground. His Charlie Hall effort was put down to a combination of being short of fitness and the faster conditions, perhaps Kempton in true mud is his forte.

    Lord Windermere’s connections said they felt the ground had gone against their horse but the fact is that this year’s race was faster than that of last year by two seconds. I strongly suspect he was simply a fluke winner.

    Road To Riches was a long range punt for me at huge odds in The King George, he went to the Lexus instead but his performance today makes me wonder what would have been had he headed to Kempton. He has beaten the King George winner today, and the form line through Many Clouds and Dynaste, who was runner up in the King George, suggest my 25/1 shot would have been far from outclassed in the Boxing Day showdown. Que Sera etc but he’s run really well today, for a horse who was on very few peoples minds after his J N Wines success.

    Today’s race seemed one where it paid to be up front and Djakadam was the only one who seemed to come through. The held up horses never really came into it and several dropped off as the race progressed. Ruby Walsh looked gutted, as if he felt sure Coneygree would tire off the front. He managed to reel in Road To Riches on the run in but couldn’t catch the game winner.

    I wouldn’t want to be the handicapper trying to sort all that out with 35 length improvements and top rated being well beaten. Coneygree looks to have made exceptional progress from his previous defeat of Houblon Des Obeaux, even if we allow that horse an off day. Djakadam is assured of a hefty rise, his official mark of 157 is clearly all wrong and it shows the difficulties we all have, and why nobody can ever be complacent about the game, when this Hennessey disappointing favourite, has just turned a 28 length deficit with the winner of that race, Many Clouds, into a 23 length superiority ie 51 lengths, on just 9lb better terms.

    Even Nostrodamus would have found it hard to see some of these turnarounds.

    10/1 Coneygree for next year with Bet Victor if that tempts anyone?

    Thanks for the good crack. Time for me to move on. Be lucky.

    #832164
    Avatar photoSteeplechasing
    Participant
    • Total Posts 6337

    Ginger, I hope Coneygree holds his form, but I suspect yesterday’s run will never be repeated. Carruthers first 2 chase wins were from the front with big margin victories. He then got a hara kiri ride from Mattie Batchelor in the RSA (I must admit, I wrote then that I thought he’d never recover from that). He proved me wrong in that he won a handful more in his career but he improved his OR by just 1lb after the RSA, and what had looked a highly promising career came to little, barring his shock Hennessy win.

    Temperament might well have played a part, but what causes bad temperament? Rides like the one in the RSA maybe? Any horse has only so much to give, and after big days and gruelling runs, a significant number never again find that form. Grand National winners are a good example.

    On the plus side, he has relatively few miles on the clock, did not finish exhausted by any means, and he’s very strongly built. I just hope they give him a long rest. The temptations for a small yard with such a horse will be many, not least the satchels of prize money at Aintree and Punchestown. We shall see. Whatever happens, it was one of those performances we will never forget.

    #832439
    Avatar photoZamorston
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1141

    They’ve said this morning that is it for the season, and that he’s come out of the race very well….fresh, eaten up well and almost like he hasn’t had a race!

    Likely to return in the Betfair and then a crack at the King George, and they reckon he’s better going right handed!

    Loving this horse like I do I took a bit of 25’s a few weeks ago (only small) for next seasons King George….after his Feltham win and the time he ran as opposed to Silviniaco Conti in the KG…

    He’s now a best priced 7/1 with Betvictor and I still think that’s an outstanding bet as we know that is his definite target and is very likely to get his ideal conditions….I’d prefer to take those odds than 3/1 on Vautour at this stage…

    And like I’ve been saying they still think there’s more to come with him!

    #832567
    Red Rum 77
    Participant
    • Total Posts 5772

    I must admit to underestimating CONEYGREE, thought HOLYWELL before the race (because he won twice at past festivals) . However one thing I definitely suspected and was right about, poor favourite was SILVINIACO CONTI, last year when leading after the last he was overtaken by LORD WINDERMERE, ON HIS OWN & THE GIANT BOLSTER. A further study revealed that he’s yet to win at Cheltenham so I concluded that while being a brilliant horse that Cheltenham doesn’t suit him.

    You've got to accentuate the positive.
    Eliminate the negative.
    Latch on to the affirmative.
    Don't mess with mister in between.

    #832599
    Avatar photoGingertipster
    Participant
    • Total Posts 34704

    As far as Silviniaco Conti goes there are many possible reasons:

    There’s one fact yesterday that stands out for me. Pulled too hard to show his form, Fehily having to tug on the reigns. Was that because he does not like Cheltenham? Was it because he can’t go slow enough to stay? Was it because they held the horse up and does not like being behind horses these days? Ridden differently than has done for both Betfair and King George. Probably a mixture of those reasons. But imo would not have stayed the trip at any course being so free. If mine he’d go for the Ryanair next year unless there were fewer front-runners in the Blue Riband… Get a view of the front and just hope he settles.

    Value Is Everything
    #832768
    Avatar photoGingertipster
    Participant
    • Total Posts 34704

    Ginger, I hope Coneygree holds his form, but I suspect yesterday’s run will never be repeated. Carruthers first 2 chase wins were from the front with big margin victories. He then got a hara kiri ride from Mattie Batchelor in the RSA (I must admit, I wrote then that I thought he’d never recover from that). He proved me wrong in that he won a handful more in his career but he improved his OR by just 1lb after the RSA, and what had looked a highly promising career came to little, barring his shock Hennessy win.

    Temperament might well have played a part, but what causes bad temperament? Rides like the one in the RSA maybe? Any horse has only so much to give, and after big days and gruelling runs, a significant number never again find that form. Grand National winners are a good example.

    May be my explanation of Carruthers of “temperamental” was over-stating the point Joe. When in front or disputing the lead Carruthers was and still is genuine and tries his heart out in a finish. However, when unable to get the wanted/needed position became increasingly moody. But look at the number of races he ran in. Is it the gruelling races that took its toll? Or just the fact he’s had so many races over his life, sure to lose form now and again. Just as a more lightly raced horse loses its form from time to time over a longer period? I see Timeform agree with you about Carruthers’s gruelling races Joe.

    Coneygree is likely to have a lot longer to get over his races than Carruthers.

    Value Is Everything
    #832835
    Avatar photothehorsesmouth
    Participant
    • Total Posts 5577

    So many highlights this week, hard to know where to start.

    I had high hopes for Holywell but with the rain yesterday morning, his chance was significantly lessened and in the circumstances he ran ran a cracker in fourth, well clear of those in behind. A pity for many of us on here that he couldn’t get into third but on that ground you’d have to be happy with him. On good ground he’d have had a bigger say.

    You do get the feeling however that this was his chance and next year’s race could be significantly stronger, with the three who beat him all improving and Don Poli and Vautour other possible contenders.

    On first impressions the right sort of horses filled the places. The front four were the unexposed types who have been showing improvement and there was a lot less of the shock factor about this year’s result than last year’s.

    Coneygree is still a novice and as such you’d expect there is more to come from him next season. Djakadam is only a six year old and the improvement he has made from the Hennessy to the Thyestes to Cheltenham is phenomenal. He put any stamina doubts to rest yesterday and while I couldn’t have had him at the prices yesterday, he certainly delivered on the hype. Road To Riches is another to have come a long way in the past year and who is to say there’s not more to come from him too.

    A huge well done to the Bradstocks for what was a brave decision: if it had backfired they were wide open for what would likely be widespread criticism. You can’t but like Coneygree’s attitude and there’s something I think every racing fan admires about a horse who goes he does from the front.

    Well done Zamarston :good:

    #832912
    Avatar photoHimself
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3777

    I expected Silviniaco Conti to be ridden much closer to the pace. Even so , the fact of the matter
    is that the clearly doesn’t stay , and just cannot perform at Cheltenham in the same way he
    does at other courses. The penny has finally dropped with Paul Nicholls that Silviniaco Conti
    will never win a Gold Cup .

    Gambling Only Pays When You're Winning

    #833135
    Avatar photoSteeplechasing
    Participant
    • Total Posts 6337

    I see Timeform agree with you about Carruthers’s gruelling races Joe.

    Interesting…what did they say?

    #835008
    stilvi
    Participant
    • Total Posts 5228

    An enjoyable race but an absolute sickener from a betting point view having backed both Djakadam (Win) and Holywell (EW) at 50/1. Top that anyone? Beaten by a horse who wasn’t a certain runner a couple of days ago and who clearly benefited from the rain. You wonder if anything could have been different but probably not. Perhaps given the way he stayed on Walsh wouldn’t have nursed Djakadam for quite so long but an all out drive from three out isn’t his bag. If you really need someone to literally lift one home with a sustained drive Geraghty is the the man. Holywell was probably more unlucky as he jumped pretty well and was always well positioned. Hard to believe he wouldn’t gone close without the rain. Might have beens don’t appear in record books though and the winner’s connections took the plunge and thoroughly deserved their success. Just a shame that the ‘Noble Lord’ wasn’t there to witness the triumph.

Viewing 17 posts - 171 through 187 (of 187 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.