The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Grand National 2011

Home Forums Big Races – Discussion Grand National 2011

Viewing 17 posts - 256 through 272 (of 529 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #346407
    Avatar photogrey dolphin
    Participant
    • Total Posts 650

    You’re probably right, especially as he would probably try and front-run and will probably overjump one anyway. I just like the horse and he does go well there.

    #346432
    KendalCavalier
    Participant
    • Total Posts 412

    Do you think Knight will scratch Calgary Bay? She’s not exactly in love with the race – she’s from the same school as Alan King on that score!

    #346439
    Avatar photogrey dolphin
    Participant
    • Total Posts 650

    I seriously hope not, as I think he’s the ideal type for the race, provided he takes to the fences.

    #346444
    Avatar photopeter .h
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1719

    Pretty big news on the RP site. Paul Nichols is apparently looking at the National for What A Friend instead of the originally suspected Totesport Bowl. Certainly would make for a very very classy National if we could get he and Tidal Bay in there. Shame we couldn’t get Midnight Chase in there too giving us 3 of the first 6 home in the Gold Cup! Can’t remember the last time we had that…

    #346447
    Avatar photorichbowman
    Member
    • Total Posts 110

    Pretty big news on the RP site. Paul Nichols is apparently looking at the National for What A Friend instead of the originally suspected Totesport Bowl. Certainly would make for a very very classy National if we could get he and Tidal Bay in there. Shame we couldn’t get Midnight Chase in there too giving us 3 of the first 6 home in the Gold Cup! Can’t remember the last time we had that…

    Judged on his Timeform Gold cup rating he’ll be running with 12lbs in hand or 15lbs on Racing Post Ratings. Couldn’t help but have a small interest at 25-1 :D .

    Sir Alex Ferguson with a National runner – the marketing dept at rfc must be rubbing their hands with glee.

    #346458
    KendalCavalier
    Participant
    • Total Posts 412

    I do hope What A Friend does run as he is one, I feel, I can safely discount. Anything gratefully received when whittling!

    #346490
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9327

    KC; what are your views on Northern Alliance if he runs? Naheez/ Bustino. Got a bit of class about him perhaps?

    #346524
    Avatar photopeter .h
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1719

    Given his Gold Cup performance and owner; i find it hard to see What A Friend not starting favourite. Mix that in with his trainer and his jockey (provided Ruby chooses him over Midnight Club) he seems almost certain to be the tabloid story going into Aintree.

    #346531
    Old Applejack
    Participant
    • Total Posts 209

    Shame we couldn’t get Midnight Chase in there too giving us 3 of the first 6 home in the Gold Cup! Can’t remember the last time we had that…

    Let me don my anorak…

    It’s happened at least once in recent times. I’m thinking of 1995. The first three in the Gold Cup, Master Oats, Dubacilla and Miinnehoma all went to Aintree, as did 5th placed Young Hustler.

    #346546
    Avatar photopeter .h
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1719

    Shame we couldn’t get Midnight Chase in there too giving us 3 of the first 6 home in the Gold Cup! Can’t remember the last time we had that…

    Let me don my anorak…

    It’s happened at least once in recent times. I’m thinking of 1995. The first three in the Gold Cup, Master Oats, Dubacilla and Miinnehoma all went to Aintree, as did 5th placed Young Hustler.

    Terrific. Terrific. :)

    Went back into the 2010 National thread to check out the deduction methods and apply them to this years race at the current standing. This was put forth by Ginger and we ended up with the eventual winner, however i went and ruined it by adding extra criteria and in the end we actually ended up with the 5th horse; Hello Bud. So here’s what Ginge would give us…

    Chuck everything rated 138 or less, because they’re not likely to get into the race.

    Chuck everything that hasn’t won a chase of at least 25f. (15 out of last 17 winners.)

    Chuck everything that hasn’t had at least 3 runs this season. (Apparently the last 15 winners had all run 3 or more times by the time of the Blue Square Gold Cup. Haven’t investigated this myself yet though, to know the precise details.)

    Take out horses under 8 years old…

    I’ve decided to add…

    Every winner since 1993 (cutting off here because i don’t know whether to count Esha Ness) have placed in the first 3 at least once at some point during the season leaving us with…

    Midnight Chase
    Deep Purple
    Synchronised
    What A Friend

    Big Fella Thanks

    Ballabrigs
    The Tother One

    Backstage*

    Chief Dan George
    Silver By Nature

    Notre Pere*

    Calgary Bay
    Killyglen
    Oscar Time
    Northern Alliance
    Grand Slam Hero

    Gullible Gordan*

    King Fontaine
    West End Rocker

    Character Building*

    That’s Rhythm

    One Cool Cookie*

    Arbour Supreme*

    Golden Kite
    Skippers Brig

    My additional criteria last year was take out horses with 11-00 or more and horses without Aintree fence experience. I do think Aintree experience is a good quality to have however and so have bolded those who have been over those big fences before, but i can guarantee you… the winner… is in that big list! Taadaa!

    (* next to those under 11-00 with Aintree exp… just for fun)

    And this is for you believers who think the likes of Merigo etc will make the list…

    Belon Gale
    Le Beau Bai
    Giles Cross

    Only ones with a weight of 10-00 – 10-03 with Ginger’s criteria…

    #346580
    Avatar photovikingflagship
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2297

    1996 also rough quest runner up in gold cup, went on to win the national a few weeks after :D

    vf

    #346585
    Avatar photopeter .h
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1719

    To prove my loyalty to my list; i have checked out my initial shortlist and taken out all who have not reached the criteria and i’m left with…

    Notre Pere
    Deep Purple
    Giles Cross
    One Cool Cookie

    I’m very happy with that list. Naturally on the day i’ll add another 1 or 2 to my selections because i just won’t be able to resist.

    #346643
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9327

    Can’t see Giles Cross getting in off 136, but rather fancy him for next year. Certainly one to follow in long distance races.

    #346721
    Old Applejack
    Participant
    • Total Posts 209

    Midday today was the second forfeit stage? Not sure if they’ll officially report on the comings and goings (well,goings mainly) today or tomorrow. Anyone have any news?

    #346746
    Avatar photopeter .h
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1719

    NATIONAL BIG GUNS STAND GROUND

    Last year’s winner Don’t Push It heads 74 remaining entries for the John Smith’s Grand National at Aintree on April 9.

    Jonjo O’Neill’s 11-year-old gave multiple champion jockey Tony McCoy an emotional first success in the world’s most famous steeplechase last year, but will be forced to concede weight all round to his rivals this time.

    The ante-post favourite is the Willie Mullins-trained The Midnight Club, while Oscar Time will bid to give Robert and Sam Waley-Cohen a huge double following last week’s Gold Cup success of Long Run.

    Backstage, Ballabriggs, the Sir Alex Ferguson-owned What A Friend and Big Fella Thanks are other major players.

    The Evan Williams-trained Deep Purple is one of eight to have been taken out, along with Tatenen, Tricky Trickster, Dream Alliance, Snowy Morning, Gullible Gordon, Meanus Dandy and The Sliotar.

    Really disappointed Deep Purple is out.

    Surprised Midnight Chase, despite his trainer insisting on the Bowl hasn’t withdrawn him… do i sense second thoughts? I hope so… well… i wish so :D

    Right now the cut off point is 10-4 with Character Building hitting number 40. So right now the balloting would be between…

    Bluesea Cracker
    Can’t Buy Time
    Character Building
    Ornais
    Piraya
    Surface To Air
    That’s Rhythm

    I’d be very surprised if all of them don’t get in with only 4 needing to go, so i guess the cut offs are going to be around…

    One Cool Cookie
    Royal Rosa
    Our Monty
    Frankie Figg
    Arbour Supreme

    Anything below them are going to be very, very lucky to make it, i reckon. Which is a shame because i’d really like to see Always Waining get in.

    #346752
    SoapStar
    Member
    • Total Posts 13

    Do you think Always Waining has any chance of getting in?
    He was my main hope on my shortlist of outsiders along with

    Roll Along
    Surface To Air
    Frankie Figg
    Bluesea Cracker

    Very disappointed if he doesn’t run :(

    #346754
    Old Applejack
    Participant
    • Total Posts 209

    Tidal Bay confirmed as being aimed at the National.

    Quite apart from the weight, you’d imagine he’ll get himself left behind again…

Viewing 17 posts - 256 through 272 (of 529 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.