The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Duke Or Soldier.

Home Forums Horse Racing Duke Or Soldier.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 22 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #8804
    johncoffee
    Member
    • Total Posts 16

    corals are offering 4 for soldier and 5’s for dukester for the arc. anyone no which is the certain horse for o’brien to run in it, or are they both running?

    #179931
    halfwaytoheaven
    Member
    • Total Posts 1387

    John,

    AOB’s stated that SOF will go straight to the Arc so if you want a safe confirmed runner bet then SOF is your man

    #179935
    davidjohnson
    Member
    • Total Posts 4491

    If Soldier of Fortune is going straight there, then I can’t see any circumstances, bar possibly an injury to Zarkava, that will see him trade at much, if any, shorter than he is now.

    #179946
    Librettist
    Member
    • Total Posts 559

    Agreed DJ.

    Youmzain and New Approach for me, by the way.

    #179949
    Librettist
    Member
    • Total Posts 559

    Apologies for drifting slightly [like an Alan Berry horse] off topic but I heard an interesting stat that Zamindar [sire of Zarkava] has only had five winner at 1m4f in the last ten years and indeed this distance has only been attempted 46 times by his progeny. In ten years!

    #179951
    johncoffee
    Member
    • Total Posts 16

    i think the break would of helped dukester 2dai, therefore he should run it in the arc instead of sof, 1m2f or 1m4f, i bet johnny would pick dukester if he had the choice of the 2 n im sure i would.

    #179953
    Avatar photoNathan Hughes
    Participant
    • Total Posts 32230

    I don’t see why they cant run the both of them, last year SOF ran with Dylan Thomas.

    Blackbeard to conquer the World

    #179972
    Librettist
    Member
    • Total Posts 559

    i think the break would of helped dukester 2dai, therefore he should run it in the arc instead of sof, 1m2f or 1m4f, i bet johnny would pick dukester if he had the choice of the 2 n im sure i would.

    Even Babelfish drew a blank.

    #179992
    Avatar photoMDeering
    Member
    • Total Posts 1688

    Soldier on, my friends. Soldier on.

    ***Fiddles in pocket to find twenty quid and start investing***

    #180274
    mellington
    Participant
    • Total Posts 21

    It has to be soldier of fortune laid out for the race this year and the ground at longchamp will probably suit him better than the duke. The duke will probably go for the breeders cup turf. Cant see them running both.

    #180295
    clivex
    Member
    • Total Posts 3420

    Someone somewhere said that Duke hadnt galloped well last week and as Segal points out in the weekender, it could be that he hasnt recovered from Newmarket. It is still a tough business keeping a horse at the very top of his game throughout a long, even with AOB’s skills

    SOF is simply held by Youmzain IMO and shouldnt be shorter

    #180306
    Sal
    Member
    • Total Posts 562

    I heard an interesting stat that Zamindar [sire of Zarkava] has only had five winner at 1m4f in the last ten years and indeed this distance has only been attempted 46 times by his progeny. In ten years!

    Zamindar’s first crop was 1999, so he had his first runners in 2001. As 2yos, they would not have run over 12f, so his first chance for them would have been in 2002. Still not great stats, but it has to be 6 and a half years, not 10.

    I also strongly suspect that those figures are GB/Ire only, so would not include horses like Corriolanus, who has won and been placed over 12f in UAE.

    And, if this is the case, it would also not include the vast majority of his 2002 and 2003 crops, which were foaled in the U.S.A. It is also worth remembering that those two American crops would not have been bred from staying damlines – those that came over here to race would have been speedier US types. Zarkava, with her strongly staying damline, is not typical of those two crops.

    So, another case of lies, damn lies and statistics…

    #180318
    Salselon
    Member
    • Total Posts 883

    Someone somewhere said that Duke hadnt galloped well last week and as Segal points out in the weekender, it could be that he hasnt recovered from Newmarket. It is still a tough business keeping a horse at the very top of his game throughout a long, even with AOB’s skills

    SOF is simply held by Youmzain IMO and shouldnt be shorter

    Couldn’t agree more Clive.

    There is just simply no way Soldier of Fortune should be any shorter than Youmzain.

    In last year’s Arc, Youmzain proved much th superior.

    SoF gained revenge when Youmzain was left with too much to do in the Coronation. However, this was followed with a more positve ride from Hughes in France next time out, which resulted in Youmzain cantering all over SoF before winning cosily. I couldn’t imagine anyone would have any excuses that day for SoF?

    Youmzain is a good example of a horse who needs his ideal conditions to perform at his best; those being a fast pace (championship pace, if you must!) and good or softer conditions.

    #180319
    Avatar photoMDeering
    Member
    • Total Posts 1688

    Some horses may never play their good hand until when it matters the most.

    Fields Of Omagh is a wonderful example. He won 13 races in 45 starts lifetime, and of those only four of any insignificanee.

    But somehow, everytime he turned up to the Cox Plate, he turned on a gear. Five appearances, two wins, one second, one third and one fourth.

    In his final start in the 2006 Cox Plate, he was written off with average form at 20/1, but I insisted to have an E-W ticket because of this unique Cox Plate transformation he undergoes, and if every other horse was just a little off guard, he could pinch the race.

    Won by a nose. Tears of joy that all horses really do have their own unique sixth sense.

    And in this case, Youmzain could be just that individual.

    #180321
    andyod
    Member
    • Total Posts 4012

    Not so.Soldier of Fortune was making his effort when Dylan Thomas squeezed the field into the rail and he had to be checked.The Official Video loses him following the winner but being checked in the final phase destroyed his chance.Murtagh rode him that day and believes he would have won.

    #180325
    Salselon
    Member
    • Total Posts 883

    I’d love for you to show me the comment where Murtagh says that?

    SoF was well beaten that day, regardless of Dylan Thomas’ meanderings across the track.

    #180340
    andyod
    Member
    • Total Posts 4012

    Sorry but I don’t have a quote.I would have put it in if I did.Maybe what he said was he will win next year but I don’t have a quote on that either.I do know he was upset with the outcome last year.Again sorry no quote.

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 22 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.