The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Cross Country – Great Advert For Ditching It

Home Forums Horse Racing Cross Country – Great Advert For Ditching It

Viewing 14 posts - 52 through 65 (of 65 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #381981
    zanybody
    Participant
    • Total Posts 89

    At the end of the day a rider made a mistake.

    Nothing stupid about it, just human error.

    We’ve all been there in some circumstance or another.

    #381987
    Avatar photoCarryOnKatie
    Participant
    • Total Posts 598

    Personally, I like watching the Cross Country races as they offer something different from the normal diet we have in this country (variety is the spice of life etc…)

    Like AngloGerman mentioned, it is the jockey’s job to know which route to take (and compared to some of the French XC courses such as Pau, Croan or the Pardubice course in the Czech Rep, Cheltenham’s – highly sanitised – XC course is a doddle to learn.

    In the case of yesterdays race, if Cheltenham had set up another 40 yards of fixed rail the carnage that ensued almost certainly would not have happened – although the jocks should have known the New Course finish was in use.

    I actually think that if the XC discipline was expanded (e.g. a race at Cheltenhams Hunter Evening – ground conditions pending of course – and maybe a second course up North, more people would gain an interest as with more runners having the opportunity to take up the discipline and more form lines could be encouraged through more opportunities rather then it being seen as an abhorration in the calendar.

    #382022
    Avatar photoDaveMonk
    Member
    • Total Posts 153

    Personally,

    I actually think that if the XC discipline was expanded (e.g. a race at Cheltenhams Hunter Evening – ground conditions pending of course –

    Ian Mc would have fun with that!!!

    and maybe a second course up North, more people would gain an interest as with more runners having the opportunity to take up the discipline and more form lines could be encouraged through more opportunities rather then it being seen as an abhorration in the calendar.

    Problems with the courses up north is they use the middle as a golf course, p2p track or are simply too small. Great idea, put it to the BHA!

    Dave

    #382027
    pilgarlic
    Participant
    • Total Posts 906

    Not keen on these races but would not object if they put them on as last race of the meeting for those who think it worth staying. Not sure why an esteemed brand like Glenfarclas wants to get involved with this. Scotsmac or Vagrant`s Choice would be more like it.

    For me, Cheltenham do not do nearly enough to define the course.Would a few weighted motorway cones at the intersection have been too much trouble? They could not even get the direction signs for the entrance to the car park right yesterday.

    #382035
    Avatar photosberry
    Member
    • Total Posts 1800

    Does anyone know how many of these races end like this each year, is it more than dangerous riding, misuse of the whip and where could this argument end up – fields of six running in dolled off lanes, hands and heels only, no turns?

    #382108
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 10174

    But would it do any harm to have a bit of tape at the end of the race to guide the jockeys onto the right course? Especially given that a horse could have died because of what happened. Don’t they do something like that at the end of the National?

    #382119
    Avatar photoGingertipster
    Participant
    • Total Posts 34704

    But would it do any harm to have a bit of tape at the end of the race to guide the jockeys onto the right course? Especially given that a horse could have died because of what happened. Don’t they do something like that at the end of the National?

    You’re dead right Moehat, there is no excuse for Cheltenham not helping riders out with a bit of tape.

    Then again, may be I’ve got early onset alzhiemers. Runs in my family. :o Although the docs say it is not herreditory. :?

    Value Is Everything
    #382142
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 10174

    I guess there’s no hope for a sport that still uses knicker elastic at the start of races, therfore sat nav is definately out of the question…?

    #382147
    Avatar photoSteeplechasing
    Participant
    • Total Posts 6337

    Interesting that W Mullins in today’s RP says Cheltenham should take part of the blame. Unusually for Ed Gillespie he’s not putting his hands up to it but I’m confident there will be signage/briefing/dolling off changes for March which will in themselves be an admission of culpability so he should offer an apology now.

    #382157
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    • Total Posts 17716

    Then again, may be I’ve got early onset alzhiemers. Runs in my family. :o Although the docs say it is not herreditory. :?

    Change your doctor – or at least get one who can spell. :mrgreen:

    #382158
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    • Total Posts 17716

    Duplicate.

    #382201
    Avatar photoGingertipster
    Participant
    • Total Posts 34704

    This is a Racing Forum Reet, not an English Language forum. :roll: Must do my lines.

    alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers alzheimers

    hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary hereditary

    At least I don’t have to say the same thing twice! :lol:

    I don’t care, I’m winning. :wink:

    Value Is Everything
    #382204
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    • Total Posts 17716

    Ginger
    Just thought it might help – to enable you find out what’s wrong wih you? :lol:

    #382209
    Avatar photoRubyisgodinthesaddle
    Member
    • Total Posts 1150

    Why get rid of it?

    Its a spectacle for old horse that lost there way. Just like the Hunter chase.

    Maybe these sort of people want to change Beechers or the Chair into a normal fence.

    Game is on a slippery slope with madness like this.

Viewing 14 posts - 52 through 65 (of 65 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.