The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Another clown of a judge (Goodwill) at Haydock

Home Forums Horse Racing Another clown of a judge (Goodwill) at Haydock

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #24384
    Avatar photoyeats
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3701

    Not for the first time, dramatic pauses while announcing the result of the photo.

    Millions of pounds at stake you clown, just give the result and melt into the background, the best officials are the ones you don’t notice.

    If you want to play Laurence Olivier get to the theatre.

    #445021
    Avatar photobetlarge
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2806

    C’mon…it’s for the punters at the course on a scorching Saturday in midsummer; all good stuff.

    You gotta twirl the edges sometimes, sell some of the the sizzle not just the sausage..!

    Mike

    #445022
    % MAN
    Participant
    • Total Posts 5104

    I must admit I don’t mind the "dramatic pauses", it adds to the tension and excitement.

    I would rather have a dramatic pause than the Judge try and attempt the world speed record in getting the result out.

    One of the best (and dare I say very brave) dramatic pauses came not from a photograph but the result of a stewards inquiry. It was at Royal Ascot a couple of years ago and the inquiry involved The Queen’s horse and it looked as though it could have gone either way. Lee McKenzie was announcing the result, "Here is the result of the Stewards Inquiry ……." and he must have paused a good five seconds, although it seemed longer "….. the placings remain unaltered." Heart stopping but gripping stuff.

    In a similar vein I’m not sure if it is fall-out from the Smith debacle but Nick Bostock was being ultra-cautious with the photographs at Leicester yesterday. Now I know Leicester is one of the worse courses in the country for making naked-eye calls, as the angles are really weird but in a couple of what looked clear head victories he still called a photograph.

    #445025
    Avatar photoyeats
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3701

    One of the best (and dare I say very brave) dramatic pauses came not from a photograph but the result of a stewards inquiry. It was at Royal Ascot a couple of years ago and the inquiry involved The Queen’s horse and it looked as though it could have gone either way. Lee McKenzie was announcing the result, "Here is the result of the Stewards Inquiry ……." and he must have paused a good five seconds, although it seemed longer "….. the placings remain unaltered." Heart stopping but gripping stuff.

    I’m surprised at Lee :lol: Afsare 2010, wonder what The Queen thought? Incidentally does anyone know which was the last horse to be disqualified from first place at Royal Ascot?

    There does seem to have been a tightening up from judges since the Smith debacle and more photo’s called, not a bad thing in my view and plenty of time then for tension etc but once the result is being announced just get it done for God’s sake, I don’t want to hear some frustrated actor getting his kicks at punters expense, Fiddler Goodwill’s voice is particularly grating anyway, if he had one like old judge Alastair Stewart then it may be acceptable.

    #445034
    % MAN
    Participant
    • Total Posts 5104

    I’m surprised at Lee :lol: Afsare 2010, wonder what The Queen thought? Incidentally does anyone know which was the last horse to be disqualified from first place at Royal Ascot?

    Afsare, that’s the one and Quadrille was HM’s horse, I remember saying to Lee afterwards "jeeze mate, you’ll end up getting sent to the bl**dy Tower if you keep pulling stunts like that one."

    I can’t, off the top of my head, remember anything getting disqualified at the Royal meeting.

    #445036
    johnt4124
    Member
    • Total Posts 36

    In 1988 Royal Gait was disqualified in the Gold Cup after winning by 5l. In 1992 he won the Champion Hurdle.

    #445038
    Mr Frisk
    Participant
    • Total Posts 163

    Topanoora, at 8-1, was disqualified from first place in the 1991 Hardwicke in favour of Rock Hopper, the odds-on favourite. Not that I’m still bitter, mind.

    #445070
    Oasisdreamer
    Participant
    • Total Posts 305

    When there is a photo finish I wish the TV screens at the racecourse would show the actual photo finish so we can mull it over for ourselves which way we think the result has went.

    I find the spinning Winning Post and the words "Photo Finish" so annoying…they add nothing to the occasion or suspense…just show us the photo please!

    I think this was a RFC invention if I’m not mistaken.

    #445081
    Avatar photoNenni
    Participant
    • Total Posts 464

    One of my all time favourite racing moments was the pause Brian Goodwill put in before announcing the result of the photo between Kauto Star and Imperial Commander in the Betfair a few years ago. It definitely added to the drama.

    And its a shame you don’t like his Burnley accent. Could be something to do with him coming from Burnley!

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.