- This topic has 30 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 19 years, 2 months ago by
.
- Posts
Hey, was going to give this a go for the next couple of weeks and see whos the best tipster on ATR. Set up 2 accounts(100 euro in each) and will follow all selections at S.P.
Sunday 7th Jan 2006<br>Dave Duggan<br>1:30 Nass 3pt Win Mister Top Notch…..3rd<br>2:30 Nass 2pt Win Chelsea Harbour….1st(11/2)<br>3:30 Nass 2pt E/W Low Expectations…Unplaced
Account Balance…€104
Matt Doyle<br>1:40 Plumpton 1pt Win The Sawyer…1st(11/8)<br>1:50 Southwell 1pt Win Vancouver Gold…3rd
Account Balance…€100.37
Monday 8th Jan 2006<br>Dave Duggan<br>No Selections (No Irish Racing)
Account Balance…€104
Matt Doyle<br>3:20 Taunton 1pt Win Alcatras…Unplaced
Account Balance…€99.37
I’m no fan of either but shouldn’t you start your experiment Paul before their selections run rather than after one has had an 11/2 winner?
Dave Duggan seems to pick plenty of winners but I really dont rate him. Some of his reasoning is bizarre and seemingly every trainer in Ireland is "shrewd". Lads in ATR do not help feeding his ego either…Gareth O’Brien is in a different league based on presenting style and over all knowledge of the Irish scene.
(Edited by Aidan at 8:30 pm on Jan. 8, 2007)
Quote: from yeats on 7:22 pm on Jan. 8, 2007[br]I’m no fan of either but shouldn’t you start your experiment Paul before their selections run rather than after one has had an 11/2 winner?<br>
Hey Yeats,
If you look back at the topic of Fantasy Team Of Presenters i suggested to Ratpak that i keep track of both selections on Sunday before the racing started and i set up 2 accounts before racing to follow their tips. I agree it does look a bit funny that i start after an 11/2 winner but that was Duggans tipping!! Who you reckon will fair out better??
I don’t take all Dave Duggan’s tips, but he’s given some good ones, in particular, he raved about Teofilo, when he was still available AP at 33/1, and he’s had a win or two in the meantime.
Also, Jayo, who won very easily the other day, oozing class.
And I was on Doyle’s tip, Sybarite Chief the other day. He had indeed shown good form early in his career, and was ready to show it again.
(Edited by Grimes at 10:35 pm on Jan. 8, 2007)
Quote: from Aidan on 8:29 pm on Jan. 8, 2007[br]Lads in ATR do not help feeding his ego either…
<br>Mate, I have absolutely no doubt this is an ‘in-joke’ led by Mr Chapman. David Duggan must have been down 100s of points in 2006, given is ott staking and basic lack of winners.
Tuesday 9th Jan 2007<br>Dave Duggan <br>No Selections (No Irish Racing)
Account Balance…€104
Matt Doyle <br>1:50 Southwell 1pt Win Mind Alert…2nd
Account Balance…€98.37
Wednesday 10th Jan 2007 <br>Dave Duggan <br>No Selections (No Irish Racing)
Account Balance…€104
Matt Doyle <br>1:00 Lingfield 1pt New York Oscar…1st(4/9)<br>3:00 Lingfield 1pt Jools…Unplaced
Account Balance…€97.81
Thursday 11th Jan 2007 <br>Dave Duggan <br>1:55 Limerick 1pt E/W Settigano…..Unplaced <br>2:25 Limerick 2pt Win Barman….Unplaced <br>2:55 Limerick 3pt Win Tax Exemption…Unplaced
Account Balance…€97.00
Matt Doyle <br>1:00 Hereford 1pt Schuh Shine…1st(10/11)
Account Balance…€98.71
Friday 12th Jan 2007 <br>Dave Duggan <br>No Selections No Irish Racing
Account Balance…€97.00
Matt Doyle <br>4:00 Wolverhampton 1pt Lazy Darren…Unplaced
Account Balance…€97.71
Saterday 13th Jan 2007 <br>Dave Duggan <br>1:25 Punchestown 3pt Win Jayo…Unplaced <br>1:55 Punchestown 2pt E/W House Of Cars…Unplaced
Account Balance…€90.00
Matt Doyle <br>3:15 Kempton 2pt Win 1pt Place Rayshan…Unplaced <br>3:30 Warwick 2pt Win Lazy D’argent…Unplaced <br>12:20 Lingfield 1pt Win Bobsobel…1st(6/4)
Account Balance…€94.21
Big day for Duggs today… He’s staked out 21 pts on the racing at Leopardstown… :o
What size bank does this man use?
Sunday 14th Jan 2007 <br>Dave Duggan <br>12:20 Leopardstown 1pt E/W Cherryhill Star…Unplaced <br>12:50 Leopardstown 2pt Win Walkin Aisy…Unplaced <br>1:20 Leopardstown 3pt Win Mister Top Notch…Unplaced <br>1:50 Leopardstown 1pt E/W Sound Witness…Unplaced <br>2:20 Leopardstown 2pt E/W New Field…3rd(10/1) <br>2:20 Leopardstown 1pt E/W Power Elite…Unplaced <br>3:30 Leopardstown 3pt E/W The Bosses Ne’…Unplaced <br>   <br>Account Balance…€76.00
Matt Doyle <br>2:20 Leopardstown 1pt Win New Field…3rd(10/1) <br>2:20 Leopardstown 1pt Win Kendor Dine…Unplaced
Account Balance…€92.21 <br>
(Edited by PaulB at 5:27 pm on Jan. 16, 2007)
Quote: from nore on 11:34 am on Jan. 14, 2007[br]Big day for Duggs today… He’s staked out 21 pts on the racing at Leopardstown… :o
What size bank does this man use?
I think hes using the European Central Bank!!!
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.