The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Scottish National 2010

Home Forums Big Races – Discussion Scottish National 2010

Viewing 17 posts - 18 through 34 (of 83 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #289872
    Avatar photorich1985
    Member
    • Total Posts 1217

    I think you’ll find I put up Gone To Lunch first fellas! :wink: Him and PDS are my two at the moment, probably won’t do any more. Killyglen was in the market when I looked last night and when it was first published around 2 weeks ago. This race would’ve been perfect again for Hello Bud to follow up, shame he went for the GN instead as the track/ground would’ve been perfect for him.

    #289882
    Avatar photoraymo61
    Participant
    • Total Posts 6328

    Here is one to throw in the mix!!!
    If he decides to send it over keep an eye out for Lochan Lacha of Tony Martin’s.He has been known to send a horse or two over and picked off some good handicaps!! I have backed it at 55 and 50 on Betfair so hope it turns up at least!!

    I would also give chances to Merigo and Poker Di Sivola too!

    #289894
    Avatar photoBig Bucks
    Member
    • Total Posts 1046

    apologies for believing the Racing Post (should know better) and quoting Halcon as top-weight.

    #289902
    fivelongdays
    Participant
    • Total Posts 693

    Two horses I like, at least at first consideration.

    Chief Dan George has ran decently here before, and he’s in great form.

    Gidam Gidam is a pretty tasty price, and we know he can go the trip.

    That said, still plenty of time!

    Twitter=@PGHenn

    So don't run, just like the others always do

    #289907
    Avatar photorich1985
    Member
    • Total Posts 1217

    Gidam Gidam will appreciate the ground too, shade high in the weights though?

    #289919
    Avatar photovikingflagship
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2300

    i think im going to go for gone for lunch, mind you that may be a jinx, every horse i choose for this race, always comes 2nd

    vf

    #289921
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    • Total Posts 17716

    Maybe we can get the forcast up then :wink:

    John Mackie would love to win this race you can bet on that. He knows more than most about what it takes to win a National from his days with Rhona Oliver plus he was a frequent visitor at Harry Bell’s back in the good old days. During a 6 year period the 2 yards won the race 4 times between them with Sebastian V, Astral Charmer Fighting Fit and Cockle Strand. A few years earlier the border yards won it 3 times on the trot with Young Ash leaf, Quick Reply and The Spaniard.

    John has given Gidam Gidam every chance to get ready for this. He pulled him out of the Midlands Grand National at the 11th hour because he simply wasn’t happy enough with him and felt there was no sense in rushing the horse who has agood future in these long distance chases. He’s only 8 and has now come of age, he will only run if he’s spot on, so if he turns up at 33/1 he’s worth at least a few quid EW.

    Very difficult race this year but obviously Ferdy’s has a great chance but it will be interesting to see what truns up and what doesn’t.

    #289922
    Avatar photovikingflagship
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2300

    ive backed antepost poker de sivola and gone to lunch

    don’t know if ive made mistake not going for CDG i soo wanted him to get in t aintree

    vf

    #289961
    Grimes
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1889

    I like Chief Dan George, but find the price of Meanus Dandy most suspicious; he so lightly-raced and although I skim lot of what I should take in, his profile looke very undistinguished. Must have another look.

    #289965
    Avatar photoZarkava
    Participant
    • Total Posts 4691

    Gordon, don’t give up hope. He came 2nd in this off top-weight, almost won a Welsh National off top-weight. Don’t fret! He may be top-weight but the others are carrying a hell of a lot more weight than they would’ve done 2 seasons ago.

    The horse is completely fresh, King’s yard’s back in a bit of form and the horse is now 20s with Coral’s. Silly, silly price. Softer ground would be better though.

    #289983
    Avatar photoRegal Steel
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1

    I like the look of THEATRICAL MOMENT and AURORAS ENCORE.

    #289985
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9327

    I’ve been looking at Auroras Encore; 33/1 with Corals at the moment. Also Scots Dragoon [always keep an eye on Nicky Hendersons raids on the north]and Gidam Gidam if he runs. Decided that Faasel won’t stay.

    #290009
    Fryern
    Member
    • Total Posts 175

    There looks a cracking ew bet in this race to me. Not been mentioned so far so once it’s a confirmed runner I’ll get my money on and then tell you. There are 39 other runners but it stands out to me. :D :D

    #290025
    Avatar photorich1985
    Member
    • Total Posts 1217

    Trends from the last 12 years (adapted from BBC forum):

    Oppose all that ran in the GN.
    7/12 were 8yo (very few younger but there have been a couple).
    7/10 finished in top 3 LTO.
    Rated 130-149 but this pretty much covers the field this year less the top weight and bottom few.
    9/10 fallen less than twice.
    1st/2nd season chasers do remarkably well.
    Average winning SP from last 10 years is 20/1.
    Form over extreme distances is vital.
    Murphy/Nicholls/Hobbs to target.

    Gidam Gidam, Out The Black and Ballyfoy meet a lot of this criteria, and all are big prices.

    #290051
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9327

    What about Chiaro? Won over 3m7f, 4th last year. Ran badly last time? I always forget to look at horses that placed in previous years. Trainer in good form. 25/1.

    #290052
    KendalCavalier
    Participant
    • Total Posts 412

    Started going a bit silly with this race.

    There is some cracking value to be had,

    Already on Poker De Sivola at 17.5 (shame Any Currency is not going)

    Gone To Lunch at 19

    Lothian Falcon at 32

    Merigo at 40

    Gidam Gidam at 44

    Hold The Pin at 55

    Cleni Boy at 130

    Ballfoy at 270

    There are major stamina doubts about a lot at the head of the market, with the exception of Poker and GTL. The last three winners of the race had already proved themselves over marathon distances and had previously won over 3m 7f and further.

    Cleni Boy does look like a stayer so I hope he gets in and Ballyfoy is by a sire that has a decent record over four miles.

    #290124
    Grimes
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1889

    I like the profile of Eric’s Charm (bar his last-time-out fall) and the fact that he’s a half-brother to Monkerhostin and another crack has a relatively low weight.

    I think he fell at the first in the GN, so it shouldn’t have taken too much out of himm and his trainer says he’s fine. Not a bother on him!

Viewing 17 posts - 18 through 34 (of 83 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.