- This topic has 53 replies, 27 voices, and was last updated 14 years, 11 months ago by
.
- Posts
He owes me £40, I reckon.
Waited all day for the good thing I thought it might be, only for him jump the last, go a couple of lengths clear before inexplicably dropping his hands what seemed like 50 yards before the line.
I’m in a rage
. Right now, I feel a life ban would be lenient. Tomorrow, I’ll settle for 4 months.Desperate mistake by the young lad and deserves a hefty ban,just hope he learns from it but it doesn’t effect him in future-he is very promising!
- Total Posts 17716
I feel sorry for the lad, he made a big mistake and doesn’t deserve the bad press he’s recieving.
All the best Peter I hope the authories see there was nothing cynical.
Of course he deserves the bad press he’s receiving; he made a monumental error.
It’s not as if the press are being harsh on him for the way he looks, or anything to do with his private life, or anything like that, they’re giving him bad press because he dropped his hands 50 yards from the line and cost punters who backed him their winnings.
What do you want the press to do exactly? Say nothing, praise him? What should they have said about him?
This is exactly why this sort of thing keeps happening; because too many people are too quick to brush it under the carpet.
Highlight his error, fine and ban him approriately, and then move on. Let’s not just say, "He’s made a mistake and doesn’t deserve the bad press he’s reciving.", because quite frankly, he does.
Before I start I will declare a vested interest as this horse was my biggest bet of the day.
Jockeys should know where the winning line is, it is their job to do so. Other riders knew where the finishing post was.
Yes people do make mistakes but this is the second time in a year he has stopped riding before the line – which is why the local Stewards did not impose a ban and referred him to the BHA.
I don’t think for one moment there was anything malicious in his actions, it was a genuine mistake – you could tell that from his reaction and he held his hands up straight away.
However he does deserve a hefty ban to hammer home it is not the sort of mistake riders should make.
It must have been pretty horrible for him coming back in – I have not heard booing like that on a racecourse for a very long time and some boozed-up racegoers were in danger of over reacting. Luckily there was some beefed up security there today – when I went to the weighing room to pick up the result of the stewards enquiry there were still quite a few racegoers outside wanting for Carberry and some hefty guys guarding the weighing room.
yes it was a bad mistake to make and he has to accept bad press but i do think a baying mob waiting for him is a bit harsh after all he is a young lad and it was a genuine mistake
I don’t think for one moment there was anything malicious in his actions, it was a genuine mistake – you could tell that from his reaction and he held his hands up straight away.
I’m not sure how you would be able to tell if a mistake like this was genuine or not, wouldn’t they look the same?
I’m not saying for a moment it was the case here but if someone did it deliberately wouldn’t they make it look like a genuine mistake?Just seen it and lets say a very basic error but it always seems to me harsh for a lengthy loss of earnings for a mistake, especially when the rules in place are not concrete enough. That said the ban must be at least 3 weeks, but they need to caveat it with a statement, saying, next jockey who drops his hands and loses a place as a result will be banned for at least 6 months. To me thats stops it. quite simple really, which is why it wont be done.
No financial interest but just watched the race now. Disgraceful riding. 28 days simply not long enough. You need to get proper bans in place to completely eradicate this kind of bollocks. Just gives racing a bad name.
Second time its happened to him in a short space of time.
One mistake can be forgiven as hes a young lad but for him to be that careless so soon is worrying for his future prospects
Should have got a 3 month ban minimum and a 3rd such offence at least a year. He cannot let it happen again or serious questions will have to be asked
I don’t think for one moment there was anything malicious in his actions, it was a genuine mistake – you could tell that from his reaction and he held his hands up straight away.
I’m not sure how you would be able to tell if a mistake like this was genuine or not, wouldn’t they look the same?
I’m not saying for a moment it was the case here but if someone did it deliberately wouldn’t they make it look like a genuine mistake?I take your point but if it was deliberate he also deserves a BAFTA nomination for his reaction afterwards
Watched the replay last night to see what had happened. Always thought it was pretty obvious where the winning post was at Uttoxeter, but what was the poat that I saw on the stand side [where he dropped his hands]? Have to say the ‘baying mob’ sounds like one of the reasons I no longer go to what used to be my favourite course. However, huge sympathy for those that lost money yesterday, it’s never happened to me so no idea what it feels like.
I’ve no problem at all with people booing in these circumstances but I’d draw the line at a "baying mob".
It was obviously a genuine mistake by Carberry but he thoroughly deserves the lengthy ban that’s on its way.
As I’ve pointed out before, at one time a ban wasn’t always automatic in these cases. To my cost, Willie Carson eased Cherry Hill down at York in 1984 – Form Book comment: fifth straight, soon hard driven, stayed on to lead inside final furlong, eased close home, caught final stride – and was fined £500 with no ban at all.
…..but what was the poat that I saw on the stand side [where he dropped his hands]?
Mo,
They had a divided bend at Uttoxeter yesterday and it was the "C" marker differentiating the two courses.
However, huge sympathy for those that lost money yesterday, it’s never happened to me so no idea what it feels like.
It is frustrating but one of the many things that can happen in racing – I think I just muttered "you stupid sod" then was more annoyed when I realised I was going to be stuck at the course longer than I had originally envisaged . . . . why is it nearly always the last race when these things happen?
I wonder of those who think Carberry should be be banned for months also believe that EVERYONE who makes a mistake at work should be suspended without pay for months with no recourse to tribunals etc, etc.
This is overreaction from those who lost a few quid. The horse could have fallen or been brought down, he could have bumped into a better one on the day, no horse is a cert.
I haven’t heard from anyone who benefited by this, and there must be some.
I don’t think he did a good job that day, far from it, but it was a mistake pure and simple. Willie Twiston Davies made one too, when he asked Baby Run the impossible question at Cheltenham, but nobody wants him banned. I know of many more instances where jockey mistakes have probably cost a race, but nobody wants them banned either
. Right now, I feel a life ban would be lenient. Tomorrow, I’ll settle for 4 months.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.