The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Muffin Man

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Tom Segal is worried, and so he ought to be. #348062
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    After all the huff and puff with regards to Tom Segal and Frankel, he’s still only willing to play EW against him.

    in reply to: Aon Chase 2011 #341167
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    I thought Carronhills was impressive considering this was his first run back after a long break.
    Jumped left, Maguire was very kind to him in the straight I thought. Off 130 he’ll win a good handicap – Will Hill Chase?

    in reply to: This Season's Irish Bumpers #339866
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    Star Neuville entered @ Newbury tomorrow.
    Looks a cracker of a race, be interesting to see how he fares.

    in reply to: Aon Chase 2011 #339852
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    7 goto post

    What A Friend
    Riverside Theatre
    Dance Island
    Ogee
    Fair Along
    Mahogany Blaze
    Noland

    Backed both Ogee & Chief Dan George eway when decs made @ 40s 1-2-3, still think WAF & RT are beatable for differing reasons.

    in reply to: Aon Chase 2011 #339748
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    He’s about 30lbs short of Gold Cup class I can just imagine Ruby and Sam or AP clambering to ask if they can get off Kauto and Denman to ride What A Friend. :shock:

    If ratings are anything to go by Riverside Theatre 165 should be giving weight to What A Friend 159 but the way it works out What A Friend has to give him 4lbs so he’s 10lbs wrong.

    I suppose it depends on whether you believe his second to Long Run in the King George is better form than What A Friend’s defeat of Money Trix in the Lexus.

    Money Trix is certainly not Gold Cup class but Long Run certainly seems to be.

    It’s not often I pay any attention to ratings but that 10lbs is a lot to ignore and surely cant be that far off the mark?

    Ratings are only one mans opinion.

    One mans 164 could be anothers 146.

    in reply to: Podcast Directory #339745
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    A TRF podcast would be a good idea.
    Either Football Ramble/Football Extra (Guardian) as the template.

    in reply to: James Willoughby – The Weakest Link #339734
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    A must read, and very much understandable to take time to "smell the roses"

    in reply to: Howard Johnson… #339698
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    Hearing is now in July.
    JHJ lawyers requested extra time to build a defence.

    in reply to: Aon Chase 2011 #339626
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    Fair enough. Riverside has won 3 times fresh and four times not. He’s also won twice at Newbury from 3 starts and came second the other. If that’s enough to rule him best fresh and RH then so be it but he’s good enough for me.

    3?

    His wins have been after the following break:
    Debut / 217 / 59 / 54 / 212 / 31 / 193

    Defeats
    35 / 27/ 13 / 25 / 79 / 37 / 75

    His best runs in defeat were after 79 days – Late rattle in the Arkle and 75 days – 2nd to Long Run

    He’s best fresh – NAP

    in reply to: Aon Chase 2011 #339590
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    :o

    Totally disagree with the above posts.

    I can’t find a more glorified woofer than What A Friend.

    His win at Aintree last season has more holes than my mothers colander. Carruthers, a well placed and likeable sort, nothing special. Nacarat wasn’t the same horse we’ve seen this season, and Tom George was having a shocker last season.
    He dogged it behind Denman in Hennessy last season and his head carriage is woeful.
    How the hell did this horse win two Gr1s, oh he beat a still maturing Joncol on ground that was too quick for him, and Money Trix, the supposed great horse of Nicky Richards which we never see over here.

    Riverside Theatre, best fresh and RH?

    This leaves it wide open for a skinner to win this imo.

    in reply to: Race planning gone mad #338770
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    One on a RH track, one LH
    One over 2m1/2f, one over 2m
    One carries different penalty structures

    Two totally different races when you end up reviewing the form.

    in reply to: Charlie Hall Chase 2010 #325230
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    Deep Purple
    Knockara Beau
    Calgary Bay
    Ollie Magern
    Barbers Shop
    Nacarat
    Thats Rhythm
    The Tother One

    in reply to: Old Roan Chase 2010 #323609
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    I’d be surprised if Monets turns up now that Geraghty is on Poquelin.
    Them two had a great partnership last season.

    in reply to: New Members Thread #323580
    Muffin Man
    Member
    • Total Posts 15

    Morning all,

    I’m sure I’ll find some like minded folk on here.
    Bring on the NH Season!

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)