The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Racing's Most Controversial Races

Home Forums Horse Racing Racing's Most Controversial Races

Viewing 17 posts - 35 through 51 (of 55 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #135560
    LUKE
    Member
    • Total Posts 271

    The Dewhurst of the late 70’s/early 80’s – the super horse beaten by a maiden, finished last of 4 having destroyed everything on all his other starts. The RP did something on it a few months ago.

    The horse that beat Gorytus was no maiden he had previously won the Middle Park -Dieses I think.

    #135613
    Avatar photoHimself
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3777

    The Dewhurst of the late 70’s/early 80’s – the super horse beaten by a maiden, finished last of 4 having destroyed everything on all his other starts. The RP did something on it a few months ago.

    The horse that beat Gorytus was no maiden he had previously won the Middle Park -Dieses I think.

    I remember Gorytus very well. Trained by Dick Hern, the colt hacked on his debut (Acomb Stakes, York) against Henry Cecil trained hotpot, which I backed that day (I think it may have been Dunbeath). He then won the Champagne Stakes at Doncaster, before starting at odds on (1/2) for the Dewhurst. Beforehand, Hern was quoted as saying Gorytus (by Nijinsky) was the best two year old he had yet trained. He was being hailed in some quarters as a superstar. His jockey, Willie Carson, thought Gorytus a good thing to win the Dewhurst. Henry Cecil and Diesis had other ideas, and so (allegedly) did the dopers. As it turned out, Gorytus sauntered
    home, beaten 37 lengths by the other three. He raced once more as a three year old (again defeated) and then retired.

    Gambling Only Pays When You're Winning

    #135646
    Fist of Fury 2k8
    Member
    • Total Posts 2930

    There have been many controversial races.

    Paul Nicholls always maintained that Playschool was doped in the Gold Cup when he was riding it.

    Possibly.

    Brownes Gazette being left at the start of the Champion Hurdle however Dermot Browne did I believe own up to doing it on purpose for some syndicate.

    Dermot Browne was involved in doping, but he was also a good story teller and I if his misplaced ego’s at work in this story.

    Graham Bradley trying to get a Gold Cup postponed at the start for betting reasons when it was snowing. Sorry I am to old to recall the years

    An apochryphal story?

    Rob

    Playschool was definitely got at totally died under the man and was fine no in great form prior to the race.he simply was not himself and the only thing that does that in such a short space of time is doping ……From first hand experience Dermot is full of crap and that’s absolute BS…..Zorro couldn’t have pulled that off……he got scoodled and was too big a twat to admit later he messed up …just making himself seem important ..Brad wouldn’t have done such a thing,:roll: well at least not without being nice about it……….a lovable rouge would best describe Brad who is totally misunderstood……..mainly by himself :lol:

    #135674
    Fist of Fury 2k8
    Member
    • Total Posts 2930

    Got to add the famous PPP….Dick Pitman’s impersonation of a sack of potatoes on Crisp on the run in at Aintree……..Pitman’s Panic Performance……shocking piece of riding

    #135676
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 10186

    the Carvills Hill, Golden Freeze Gold Cup was the first controversial race that I came across when I renewed my interest in racing..

    #135862
    Fist of Fury 2k8
    Member
    • Total Posts 2930

    Anyone remember the horse they said Daivid Goulding stopped ………..was a 4 horse race, I think, and he dropped him out the back……..David was raging with the Stewards said they hadn’t a bloody clue what they were talking about and only an idiot would even try and to stop a horse in such a small field.

    #135908
    Avatar photopod
    Member
    • Total Posts 41

    February 1967 – Newbury – the then Schweppes (now the Tote) Gold Trophy Handicap Hurdle and the case of the winner who made his own dope…..or did he.

    Although 40 years have elapsed since the drawn-out aftermath of this race, the events surrounding the controversial victory of HILL HOUSE are still worth a read at…..

    http://www.findonvillage.com/0514_hilll_house_and_all_that.htm

    #135920
    Fist of Fury 2k8
    Member
    • Total Posts 2930

    What the story doesn’t tell you Pod is the lead up to Hill House.

    Ryan Price had already won the race twice with Rosyth and been suspended.

    He almost won it a third time with Rosyth but was beaten by Elan rtrained by John Sutcliffe who was also pulled up by the Stewrds after landing ahge gamble. The following year Ryan Price was at it again and landed yet another huge touch with Le Vermontois and then the daddy of them all Hill House (1967). Ryan Price new he was for the high Jump when the horse won but as you posted handled well and got away with it…..cost him a pitance to what they had taken out the books.

    He almost won the race again with Major Rose but not even the Capt could stop Persian War which was probably the best race for the Scheppwes Gold trophy ever.

    Only a few years later I was lucky to be told to have my mortgage on Bootlaces who was again a huge gamble on the day….Cala Mesquida was another and Within the Law helped easterby’s travelling head lad Mick Lambert set up training when he backed the horse at a huge price……..It seemed ever year someone somewhere landed a huge touch in the race and is probably the most controversial hurdle race in history for that reason alone.

    #136144
    Irish Stamp
    Member
    • Total Posts 3176

    The Dewhurst of the late 70’s/early 80’s – the super horse beaten by a maiden, finished last of 4 having destroyed everything on all his other starts. The RP did something on it a few months ago.

    The horse that beat Gorytus was no maiden he had previously won the Middle Park -Dieses I think.

    I didn’t mean Diesis, was there not a maiden in 2nd or 3rd in that race?

    #136155
    Venusian
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1665

    That would be 2nd placed Gordian.

    #136166
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    • Total Posts 17716

    Anyone remember Ile De Chypre’s run in the 88 King George handicap?
    As I recall, he was 2l clear going into the last furlong and looking to win comfortably when he swerved violently across the course and unshipped the unfortunate Greville Starkey. Later said to be the work of someone in the grandstand with some kind of high-pitched sonic gun, though that takes some swallowing.
    Wonder if the same guy was at Devon Loch’s Grand National? :lol:

    #136664
    thejackal
    Member
    • Total Posts 50

    Not sure if this has been mentioned but cahervillahow’s disqualification in the whitbread gold cup was quite controversial at the time – think docklands express was awarded the victory

    A real good but someways unlucky servant for Mouse Morris, he was beaten a short head in the irish national 3 weeks before the above invident and was also second in the national that never was in 1993

    #137308
    Avatar photochloed
    Member
    • Total Posts 433

    have to agree about nureyev losing the 2000 gns , but happily i had a late phone call from the course and got on known fact.
    Ille de chypre however i do believe starkey, i had backed it and remember it well, and a horse does’nt spook like that for nothing.

    #137339
    Avatar photograysonscolumn
    Participant
    • Total Posts 7034

    Good call, Jackal – Cahervillahow’s connections must really have upset the gods at some point.

    gc

    Jeremy Grayson. Son of immigrant. Adoptive father of two. Metadata librarian. Freelance point-to-point / horse racing writer, analyst and commentator wonk. Loves music, buses, cats, the BBC Micro, ale. Advocate of CBT, PACE and therapeutic parenting. Aspergers.

    #137528
    carvillshill
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2778

    Not sure if this has been mentioned but cahervillahow’s disqualification in the whitbread gold cup was quite controversial at the time – think docklands express was awarded the victory

    I’ll never forget that incident as long as I live Jackal- there was a real feeling in Ireland of anti-Irish bias, as the interference was minimal. Sadly it was in the days before "double result" so we all lost our dough as well!

    #137540
    thejackal
    Member
    • Total Posts 50

    indeed it wasn’t the most well received ruling in Ireland

    Strange that Cahervillahow, although not really a top class horse, was the flagship 3 miler for ireland for that generation. I used to love the owners silks – pink with red hearts, nice novelty without being too gimicky. She had another good 3mile mare who’s name escapes me now

    How our standards have increased since then and now expect or look for a viable gold cup contender

    #137546
    carvillshill
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2778

    Think her name was Mrs Valentine (the owner, not the mare!)

Viewing 17 posts - 35 through 51 (of 55 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.