The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

William Buick is the most overrated jockey of my lifetime

Home › Forums › Horse Racing › William Buick is the most overrated jockey of my lifetime

Viewing 15 posts - 52 through 66 (of 66 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1772016
    GM23
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1410

    Needs banning for that ride on Touleen. Barely rode her at all in the final half furlong which ensured he lost 3rd at the line to Murphy.
    I’d be absolutely fuming if I was a place pot backer.

    If I owned the horse, I’d revoke his fee for that also.

    #1772588
    Mike007
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9975

    Talk Of New York – what happened?

    #1772589
    Avatar photoRefuse To Bend
    Participant
    • Total Posts 4710

    I think the horse is a difficult ride he switched him off then the horse decided he wasn’t going to pick up until it was too late.

    The more I know the less I understand.

    #1772590
    Avatar photoNathan Hughes
    Participant
    • Total Posts 35520

    Pulled hard early, tried to settle him, left too much to do. Made ground up late but possibly lost enough energy early. Either that or Buick was over confident or both

    Gaelic Warrior Gold Cup Winner 2026

    #1772670
    Helcatmudwrestler
    Participant
    • Total Posts 998

    Tale of New York and Opera Ballo cut from same cloth , loads of ability , tons of wasted energy in the run . What with his good 2 year old that won’t go straight it must be frustrating for stable .

    #1778423
    GM23
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1410

    Hopefully it doesn’t take Loughnane long to displace him as No1.

    His ride on Notable Speech at the Breeders Cup was an absolute disgrace and that’s twice in a single season he ballsed up on him at that track. He’s a joke compared to Ryan Moore.
    Newmarket is about the only track where he’s competent.

    Loughnane at only 20yo will take time to reach his peak but in the meantime, he surely can’t be any worse than Buick.

    #1778425
    Avatar photoHe Didnt Like Ground
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9541

    Billy is already better than Buick , it’s a AP situation , he was better than most pros as a 5lb/3lb claimer, Billy was to , the ride in the US was horrific

    Pick 3 on Saturday champion 2025/2026

    #1778426
    LD73
    Participant
    • Total Posts 4290

    This is not going to end well unless they have strict guidelines on who rides what and quite frankly having two retained riders on the same level is at some point going to end up with one being relegated to the 2nd jockey position and given their respective ages you can only see that happening to Buick.

    Billy hasn’t had the number of high profile rides that Buick has had but as he does there will be for sure times when he rides a bad tactical race like Buick did in the BC Mile and those BC turf races always run a higher risk of encountering traffic problems due to the very tight nature of the inside turf courses……lets face it Ryan’s ride on BC could have equally gone just as south on him if Tiffany and Diamond Necklace had not parted like the Red Sea up the straight and left the gap that Ryan burst through on to win.

    Buick is a very good rider (one of the best that sit underneath Ryan) and the only thing that stops him being on Ryan’s level is that he does make more tactical mistakes although that is a relative thing when those mistakes are always going to be compared to Ryan and not the other jockeys that are on his level.

    #1778438
    Avatar photoHe Didnt Like Ground
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9541

    The problem is Ryan won and he didn’t , it’s a fine line and maybe Ryan got the rub of the green but Stevie Wonder can see Billy is the future … the near future

    Pick 3 on Saturday champion 2025/2026

    #1778451
    mickeyjp
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2053

    Godolphin dont exactly have a great stable of top horses going into next season so cant see billy getting that many top chances though probably a matter of time before he displaces buick. Buick always seems a smug git to me.

    #1778456
    Mike007
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9975

    “Godolphin dont exactly have a great stable of top horses going into next season”

    They have decent chances in both Guineas. I hope they win the 1000 one anyway ;)

    #1778461
    LD73
    Participant
    • Total Posts 4290

    HDLG – I don’t think anyone is saying Billy isn’t the future be it near or not.

    He can probably learn quite a bit from Buick over the next few months to a year or so and it will be interesting to see who gets jocked up on Desert Castle in the 2000g and Musical Times in the 1000g next season.

    Appleby is where 99.9% of Godolphin’s best horses reside so that is where any potential conflict will arise from or maybe Godolphin will ensure they are doubly represented in both races and have Billy on the second string to diffuse any potential issues.

    #1778462
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 10354

    I’m really concerned about how Billy is going to keep his weight down. I guess he needs to be riding good horses from the top stables because he certainly won’t be able to continue riding at extremely low weights in handicaps.

    #1778463
    Avatar photoHe Didnt Like Ground
    Participant
    • Total Posts 9541

    What’s Billy going to learn ? , I’m sure he will make mistakes but he already won big races ( Inc a classic ) , he’s going to watch Moore not Buick …

    Pick 3 on Saturday champion 2025/2026

    #1778475
    LD73
    Participant
    • Total Posts 4290

    If he has any sense at all (and all evidence suggests he does even at such a young age), he will be the proverbial sponge and soak up lessons from both of them – Buick has been Godolphin’s retained jockey for a long time and would be a font of information on how the set up works and other things that the public have no clue about.

    You can always learn from others whatever age you are, even if all it is is a lesson in what not to do.

Viewing 15 posts - 52 through 66 (of 66 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.