The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

Rejoining the EU

Home › Forums › Lounge › Rejoining the EU

Would you vote to rejoin the EU?

Do you believe that the UK should rejoin the European Union?

You must be logged in to participate.
  • Yes
  • No
Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 34 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1776863
    Avatar photoGladiateur
    Participant
    • Total Posts 7477

    Very simple: you either understand economics or you don’t.

    #1776903
    Avatar photobefair
    Participant
    • Total Posts 2305

    Such an avoidable act of self-harm, plus it has really screwed my own little corner of the UK (N Ireland)

    #1776923
    Avatar photoPurwell
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1642

    The damage has been done.

    I've stumbled on the side of twelve misty mountains
    I've walked and I crawled on six crooked highways
    #1776927
    Avatar photoDrone
    Participant
    • Total Posts 6440

    I voted no simply because rejoining would in all likelihood take years to negotiate.

    What I would welcome is to follow the proposed ‘associate membership’ mooted for Canada which should/could/might be simpler and quicker to organise.

    #1776977
    Avatar photoGladiateur
    Participant
    • Total Posts 7477

    “I voted no simply because rejoining would in all likelihood take years to negotiate.”

    All the while losing an estimated £100 billion per year for the British economy.

    (insert slow clap emoji)

    #1776980
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 10354

    We’ll never get the favourable terms that we had before. But in a world that is getting more and more dangerous there is strength in unity. And we can never trust America again.

    #1776998
    Avatar photoWilts
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3609

    I voted “No”, despite (surprisingly to some) voting Yes to Remain, back in 2016.
    That ship has sailed and the last thing the UK needs right now is a re-run of EU v NO EU. It would absolutely dominate UK politics for years.
    And right now, HMG has much more important, and immediate, things to sort in the coming years. Debt, Welfare reform, policies and tax policies to create growth, etc.
    The EU is NOT what it was; it is currently having its own internal issues, across its member countries.
    It’s 2 biggest, France and Germany, are in a state of flux.
    By all means get closer, co-operation on key global matters.
    New trade agreements the UK has with other countries would likely have to be amended, even ditched.
    It’s time to look forward.
    The £100bn annual ‘shortfall’ also has its doubters. Plenty of insight out there questioning that figure.
    The most simple element is the fact the UK no longer has to pay the EU a c£20bn contribution; wasnt included in those £100bn estimates.

    Burnham et all needs to get a grip first on setting out actions, not just words, of how they’re going to turbocharge growth. As yet, i’ve seen little sign of urgency on that matter.

    #1777000
    nwalton
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3851

    Voted no because i am a rwnj

    #1777001
    Avatar photoGladiateur
    Participant
    • Total Posts 7477

    “Voted no because i am a rwnj”

    There was no need to explain; we knew that anyway. 😂

    #1777002
    Avatar photoGladiateur
    Participant
    • Total Posts 7477

    “The £100bn annual ‘shortfall’ also has its doubters.”

    The actual number may be disputed, but is there anyone in the country who honestly believes that we are economically better off after alientating our biggest trading partner? 🤔

    #1777003
    Avatar photoRefuse To Bend
    Participant
    • Total Posts 4710

    Unless we know what happens otherwise there is no way of knowing. We can all say it would have been different if……… but we don’t know how different and it what way different.

    The more I know the less I understand.

    #1777004
    Avatar photoNathan Hughes
    Participant
    • Total Posts 35520

    I thought it was daft giving the option to vote in the first place

    Gaelic Warrior Gold Cup Winner 2026

    #1777006
    Avatar photoGladiateur
    Participant
    • Total Posts 7477

    “I thought it was daft giving the option to vote in the first place”

    Cameron. Enough said.

    #1777007
    moehat
    Participant
    • Total Posts 10354

    A greater majority should have been factored in. In fact it didn’t have to be implemented anyway; a referendum is only advisory I believe? Wasn’t it Corbyn that called for article something or other to be implemented? I can’t remember anything since Thatcher that has caused so much unpleasantness in this country.

    #1777018
    Avatar photoDrone
    Participant
    • Total Posts 6440

    A greater majority should have been factored in. In fact it didn’t have to be implemented anyway; a referendum is only advisory I believe?

    Agreed, but it’s worth remebering that the 1975 referendum on remaining part of the then EEC was also held as a simple majority (50%+) ballot, and Harold Wilson was on record as saying “the Government will accept your decision — whichever way it goes” so presumably Cameron and his advisors thought it best to run the 2016 in the same way.

    As it turned out the 1975 referendum ended up with a two-thirds ‘supermajority’ anyway: 67% to 33%.

    Likewise, both the 2011 AV referendum and the 2014 Scottish Independence referendum were simple majority ballots, the results of which were to be honoured.

    #1777098
    Richard88
    Participant
    • Total Posts 3921

    Obviously ‘yes’ is the ideal position as anyone with a modicum of common sense knows but rightly or wrongly it’s more complicated than that now.

    (surprisingly to some) voting Yes to Remain, back in 2016

    Doesn’t surprise me at all. Anyone who even vaguely understands the economy would have voted Remain. There was a solid pro-EU base on the moderate right such as the ‘One Nation’ Tory types. It was never a purely left/right thing.

    People can dispute the £100bn figure all they want, they are free to produce the evidence of the economic benefits if they have any but of course they don’t. Or they could tell us what level of economic damage is acceptable as a trade off for all the other benefits, if anyone can describe any that is.

    The right wing press froth at the mouth every time anyone suggests anything vaguely bringing us closer to the EU as a ‘Brexit betrayal’. Brexit itself in fact was and is the betrayal. Russia and other foreign chums are very pleased with all the useful idiots who voted for it.

    I think the referendum would be a distant memory by now had it gone the other way, especially given what’s gone on since. Of course there would always be a Eurosceptic crowd but they wouldn’t be nearly big enough to force further serious debate on it. The fact that we are still having it says it all.

    #1777543
    Blackcountry Kid
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1097

    To say that Burnham or Starmer before him indeed Labour and EU devotees of all parties in general have a position to negotiate from is quite laughable because having shown their hand in how eager they are puts Brussels firmly in control and holding all the aces. Enabling Brussels to dictate take it or leave it terms no matter how detrimental to this country.
    The simple truth is that since 2016 the UK has done better than the EU economically, despite the screaming and shouting by remoaners. Yes the UK hasn’t done great but the EU has done worse (the public seem to listen to those that scream the loudest and longest). The EU is in decline has been for years and forecast to continue to do so as a share of world GDP. Why shackle the UK to a rotting corpse of about 8-10% of the world population and have Brussels dictate the terms you can trade with 90% of the world’s people?
    The EU is corrupt, much more than the UK, they make ours look like rank amateurs, and have shown this by time after time going after the whistle blowers not the perpetrators.
    My favourite being when just after the turn of the century they sacked the chief accountant, Marta Sandreasen, for saying their accounting methods were flawed. I believe she termed the EU’s book keeping as ‘Enron style’. For those unfamiliar with the Enron scandal, they committed fraud on a massive scale with their unethical business practices. For years on the run up to 2016 the EU’s auditor’s refused to sign off the accounts because around 4%-5% of the money couldn’t be accounted for but the finance ministers voted through acceptance, with one or two exceptions, (if you controlled the finances of a company or large organisation or even a small one and you told the board year after year that 5% of the revenue has vanished and you didn’t know or care what had happened how long do you think you would stay in the job or before police were called in?) But year after year this happened with the EU finances.
    Above I mentioned that Brussels would be able to dictate the terms to the UK this would include free movement and adopting the Euro as the national currency besides having to accept whatever loony laws and regulations they consistently pass which has left them in an economic straitjacket.
    How many people can say they know the reason the Euro was introduced?
    Not an awful lot I would guess as Brussels hasn’t even told it’s citizens the true reason behind it.
    First a question … ‘what has every country got, whether they use the Euro or not, that Brussels doesn’t have?’
    Answer … a tax system to fund itself and another step in the creation of the ‘Federal States of Europe’ At present Brussels has to exist on handouts by member states, another reason they want us back as a cash cow as only one of the two countries that regularly paid in more than they received in grants.
    Just a few things for the remoaners/rejoiners and Brussels loonies to throw mud at anyone who dares to disagree with them.
    good luck to all

Viewing 17 posts - 1 through 17 (of 34 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.