The home of intelligent horse racing discussion
The home of intelligent horse racing discussion

1973 Grand National

Home Forums Horse Racing 1973 Grand National

Viewing 3 posts - 18 through 20 (of 20 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #341969
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    • Total Posts 17716

    The 1977 race saw two good horses (Winter Rain and Zetas Son) killed as well, and yet I haven’t met anyone who was soured by such an initial experience.

    No. The ethos was different then. Death was an accepted fact of life, not something that only happened (especially to animals) if

    "someone was to blame"

    .

    People who had been through at least one and possibly two World Wars were more hardened to the idea of seeing death unfolding in front of their eyes. And because those older generations (50+) were stoic about it, and children were not taught as they are today that emotional display was

    "good"

    and valuable

    "self-expression"

    , few if any were

    "soured"

    by these experiences.

    Today, although human nature has not changed, social

    mores

    certainly have. A young person would fear to be thought heartless and cruel by his or her peer group, if they didn’t at least say they’d been

    "soured"

    by seeing the screens go up, and put off this nasty sport for life.

    Just a thought: was there perhaps something more honest about seeing it happen in the open? But of course there’s no going back……

    #341980
    Avatar photoPurwell
    Participant
    • Total Posts 1514

    Today, although human nature has not changed, social

    mores

    certainly have. A young person would fear to be thought heartless and cruel by his or her peer group, if they didn’t at least say they’d been

    "soured"

    by seeing the screens go up, and put off this nasty sport for life.

    Just a thought: was there perhaps something more honest about seeing it happen in the open? But of course there’s no going back……

    Which does not explain why these "young persons" are a damn sight more violent in everyday life than my generation were.

    I've stumbled on the side of twelve misty mountains
    I've walked and I crawled on six crooked highways
    #341985
    Anonymous
    Inactive
    • Total Posts 17716

    Which does not explain why these "young persons" are a damn sight more violent in everyday life than my generation were.

    I’m not sure they are,

    Purwell

    : much of that feeling is a perception, an urban myth rather than a reality.

    There’s a hard core of inner city violence, sure, but then there always was – it’s just that it didn’t get splashed all over the papers in the 1950’s. Rereading

    "Brighton Rock"

    for example, acts as a salutary reminder that nothing much changes.

    What does happen differently now, is that school children (as young as 5) are encouraged to sit round in a circle revealing and sharing their emotional feelings. The development of

    "emotional intelligence"

    is placed above development of the other sort. Thus also the green screens (round the jockeys now as well as the horses) so as not to risk upsetting people or disturbing their emotional equilibrium. All rather Disney….

Viewing 3 posts - 18 through 20 (of 20 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.